Fried hard, crisp edges, soft center. That is the whole game.Photo: Experience PAMark Wiens starts his Reading Terminal Market run at the Dutch Eating Place, and the scrapple comes first. Same counter this article sends you to.Video: Mark Wiens / YouTube
Most of the country looks at scrapple sideways. Philly orders it without blinking, extra crispy, next to the eggs.
That is because scrapple is ours. Not borrowed, not adopted. Born here, raised here, and defended here like a cheesesteak with the wrong cheese on it.
Some call Scrapple 'Eyes, ears and assholes.' And damn is it delicious!
The loaf of record. Philadelphia's Favorite, right on the package. Photo: Habbersett via GoldbellyMoe Train
What it actually is
Scrapple is pork scraps and trimmings, the head, the heart, the liver, the parts left after the hams and the bacon are spoken for, boiled down into a rich broth. The meat gets minced fine and goes back into that broth with cornmeal and buckwheat flour, sage, thyme, and black pepper. It sets up in a loaf pan, gets sliced, and hits a hot flat top or a cast iron pan.
Done right, the outside fries into a crisp shell and the inside stays soft and rich. That contrast is the whole game. A pale, floppy slice is a failed slice.
The old farm saying is that scrapple uses everything but the oink. That is not an insult. That is the point. Nothing wasted, everything earned.
Born here
Scrapple came over with German settlers, who called it panhaas. The first recipes on this side of the ocean were written by those settlers right around Philadelphia and Chester County in the 1600s and 1700s, swapping in cornmeal for what they could not get back home.
By the 1820s, printers were already calling it Philadelphia scrapple. The city put its name on it two hundred years ago and never took it off.
Lancaster County makes a fine loaf, and theirs leans harder on the liver. The Philly style runs milder and cleaner, sage and black pepper up front, built for a diner plate. Both are real. Only one of them is the hometown standard around here, and it is not made in a farmhouse.
The loaf wars
In 1863, Isaac Habbersett started mass producing scrapple in Middletown Township, Delaware County. Habbersett became the loaf of record, the one that calls itself Philadelphia's Favorite Scrapple right on the package, and it still holds about half the market in this city.
Yes, a company in Wisconsin owns Habbersett now, and yes, it is made in Delaware these days. Philly has grumbled about both facts for years. The recipe never changed, so the grumbling stays affectionate. RAPA, the other big loaf since 1926, has its loyalists, and the brand argument at a diner counter can run longer than the meal.
That argument is a Philly birthright too. Nobody outside this region cares enough to have it. We do.
The Philly standard
Here is how it works in this city, and it is not up for much debate.
The slice gets fried hard. Crisp edges, deep brown, soft center. If it bends, it goes back. My standard is extra crispy, every time.
It rides next to eggs and toast, or it goes full sandwich: scrapple, egg, and cheese on a roll, a standing order at delis and diners all over the city. My build is sunny side up eggs and cheese, so the yolk runs into every crunchy bite. It is damn good as a breakfast sandwich. That is not hype, that is breakfast.
Then comes the one real fight. Ketchup on top, maple syrup, or apple butter. Families have positions. Diners have heard all of them. There is no wrong answer, but there is your answer, and you will defend it. Mine is syrup. Maple syrup on extra crispy scrapple is the move, sweet against the salt and the crunch.
North Jersey can keep the pork roll argument. Down here, the breakfast meat with a line behind it is scrapple.
Where it is done right
The Dutch Eating Place inside Reading Terminal Market has been serving Pennsylvania Dutch cooking since 1991, by the shop's own count, and its crispy scrapple is the plate people point to when they want a first timer converted. Crisp shell, soft middle, no shortcuts.
Down in South Philly, the Penrose Diner keeps scrapple on the menu where it belongs, next to the pork roll, holding its own. That is the Philly diner test: if scrapple is not on the menu, it is not really a Philly diner.
The last word
Scrapple never tried to be pretty. It is a loaf built from scraps by people who refused to waste a thing, and Philly turned it into a standard the rest of the country still does not understand.
Order it extra crispy, syrup on top. And if somebody at the counter wants to argue Habbersett against RAPA, or ketchup against my syrup, let them. That argument is home.
Cinnamon roll mac and cheese sounds like a dare somebody lost. Kraft put it in a blue box anyway, parked a Chili Crisp box right next to it, and sent...