Sweets

Jeni's Turned the Pepper Jelly Appetizer Into Ice Cream

November 18, 2026 • 1 min read • By Moe Train
A pint of Jeni's Red Pepper Jelly ice cream with scoops of cream cheese ice cream and red pepper jelly ribbons on top
The whole appetizer plate, crackers included, now lives in a pint. The party just moved to the freezer.Photo: Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams via PR Newswire

Somebody at Jeni's looked at the easiest appetizer on earth and thought, that should be ice cream. A block of cream cheese, a jar of red pepper jelly poured over the top, crackers on the side. No cooking, no recipe, and the plate is empty in ten minutes at every party.

Jeni's announced Red Pepper Jelly on November 17, and the flavor is a straight copy of that plate. The base is cream cheese ice cream. Ribbons of red pepper jelly run through it, tangy and sweet with a small kick of cayenne at the end. A salty, buttery cracker crumble is folded in, so the crackers made the trip too. The jelly is made for Jeni's, and the whole pint lands salty, sweet and a little hot at once.

Somebody at Jeni's looked at the easiest appetizer on earth and thought, that should be ice cream.

Moe Train

It follows the Splendid Holiday Collection from earlier this month, Sticky Toffee Pudding and Boozy Eggnog, and it's the odd one at that table on purpose. Pies and cakes are sweet all the way through. This one fights back a little.

Red Pepper Jelly is out now by the scoop and the pint at Jeni's scoop shops and by the pint at jenis.com, while supplies last. Jeni's also runs its biggest online deal of the year November 25 to 30: $20 off six pints or more with the code TWENTYOFF, plus free shipping.

What's your pick: pepper jelly on the appetizer plate or in the pint?

Back to all food news